by Gideon Marcus
The Big Guns
Thanksgiving is over, and the holiday season will officially begin tonight with the lighting of the first of the Hannukah candles. After that, it's just a short skip and a jump to that more widely celebrated holiday.
I am, of course, referring to the Winter Solstice.
It is an appropriate season, then, for science fiction's most-read magazine, Analog, to finish its year of publication with a bang. Fantasy and Science Fiction is fond of issuing "All-Star" magazines, in which the majority of the authors are big names. The December 1964 Analog isn't so dubbed, but nevertheless, it's chock full of heavy hitters. Let's take a look!
Armed Assault
by Robert Swanson
Tempestuous Moon, by Joseph H. Jackson
It has been the subject of wives' tales and farmers' almanacs that the phases of the Moon have an effect on the weather. In particular (they maintain), some points in the lunar cycle are likelier to be rainy than others. And now Analog has got a breathless article confirming the folk wisdom. Take that, doubting eggheads!
It's true that (editor) Campbell is notorious for printing the worst pseudoscience pieces, and Jackson's article is mostly blather. However, if his data be accurate, they are compelling. While the phases of the Moon should have no effect on the Earth, per se, they do correspond to geometries between the Sun and the Moon with respect to the Earth. And both of those bodies do have a profound effect on our planet every day in the form of tides. I can conceive that a strong tide, for instance when the Sun and Moon's forces combine to cause Spring Tides, might create lower atmospheric pressures, reducing the amount of moisture the air can hold, causing rains. Neap Tides would have the opposite effect.
Or it could all be garbage. Are there any pieces in reputable journals?
Plague on Kryder II, by Murray Leinster
Calhoun the interstellar Med Service man and his adorable pet/assisant, Murgatroyd, are back. This time, they are investigating an impossible plague, one which seems to suppress the immune system rather than directly infecting the body. Worse, this disease kills tormals, the monkey-like race that Murgatroyd belongs to. Since this latter is an impossibility, tormals being immune to all diseases, Calhoun suspects foul play.
by Kelly Freas
I love the Med Service stories. Sadly, they are suffering from the same malaise that has infected all of Leinster's writing to date. It causes him to write only in short, declarative statements, often repeating himself for no reason. Also, this tale's solution is given mostly in exposition, which kills the fun of the mystery.
Still, even substandard Calhoun and Murgatroyd is pretty fun, and the picture of the sick tormal is too cute for words. Three stars.
Shortstack, by Leigh and Walt Richmond
by Kelly Freas
The latest vignette by the Richmonds is an odd one, more a dramatized advertisement for a unique power generator. It uses the heat differential between the top and bottom of a plastic cylinder to drive an engine and also to distill water.
Harmless, kind of interesting. Three stars.
Contrast, by Christopher Anvil
by Kelly Freas
A man trapped out in a wilderness that would give Deathworld a run for its money gets buzzed by an obnoxious tourist. When said sightseer falls out, the hermit takes his skimmer and rides to safety. The moral of the story: don't take what you have for granted, and a stint in the muck might do you good.
Enjoyable, despite the smugness of the ending. Three stars.
Sweet Dreams, Sweet Princes (Part 3 of 3), by Mack Reynolds
by Robert Swanson
We return to the world of the early 21st Century, where society has stratified into stagnancy: in both East and West, the top 1% rule everything, the bottom 90% are jobless and tranquilized, and only the middle 9% have any real agency. Last time, Estruscan professor and gladiator-extreme, Denny Land, had just won a tripartite contest over custody of a Belgian scientist who had invented anti-missile missiles, something with the potential to destabilize the world.
But when the Americans go to pick up the scientist, he has disappeared! And rather than express disconcertment, Land's boss, Joe Mauser seems almost unsurprised…
Land goes back to his old school with a promotion and bump in caste, but he can't hide his frustration and disenchantment. Reenter Bette Yarborough, who recruits Land into the Sons of Liberty to try to upend the whole rotten world order. And then comes an even unlikelier ally in the cause — former foe and Sov-world agent, Yuri Malshev. Together, can the three create a revolution?
And what if the revolution has already happened, and nobody knows?
This installment was the most engaging, well-paced and thoughtful, though there may have been one too many wheels within the wheels. Perhaps a Part IV would not have been amiss. I was grateful that Bette turned out not to just be a love interest (though more than one female in the universe would have been nice). If anything, Denny and Yuri had more chemistry…
Anyway, four stars for this segment. Call it three and a half for the novel as a whole. I appreciate that Reynolds is willing to make "if this goes on" predictions. I wonder how right he will prove to be…
Rescue Operation, by Harry Harrison
by Adolph Brotman
An alien astronaut crash lands on the shore of an Adriatic village. Injured and barely conscious, he is taken to a local scientist for help. But can an effective treatment be developed in time?
This simple story is given depth and emotion by the unusually talented Harrison, who will probably get my nomination for one of the year's best authors. Four stars.
The Equalizer, by Norman Spinrad
by Adolph Brotman
In Israeli's Negev desert, a scientist wrestles with his conscience — and his superior — over the the new bomb he's invented. On the one hand, it will give the little Jewish state inordinate power; on the other hand, power never remains exclusively owned for long.
An interesting think piece whose title has a double meaning. Three stars.
High Marks
Well, color me surprised! Analog, normally a disappointing performer, scored a respectable 3.2 stars — second only this month to the superlative Galaxy (3.6). Science Fantasy and Worlds of Tomorrow both scored an even 3 stars, largely thanks to better-than-average long pieces balancing out less impressive small ones.
And on the negative side of the ledger, we have a lackluster IF (2.8), a still-Davidson weighted Fantasy and Science Fiction (2.6), and Cele G. Lalli's mags did worst of all: Fantastic got just 2.3 stars, and Amazing broke the two barrier, scoring a jaw-dropping 1.9. What happened?
Women published just 5 and a half of all the stories in magazines this month, all of them very short. Betty Friedan would be rolling in her grave, and she's not even dead!
Ah well. 1965 approaches, a chance to wipe the slate and start anew. But before then, you will want to see our Galactic Stars awards when they come out in a few short weeks! Then you won't have to wade through the dross to get the gems — we'll have done the work for you.
Happy Holidays!
[Come join us at Portal 55, Galactic Journey's real-time lounge! Talk about your favorite SFF, chat with the Traveler and co., relax, sit a spell…]
For some reason that I'll have to muse upon, a heroic guy named "Denny Land" sounds strangely attractive to me.
I have to admit that the idea of a hero named "Denny Land" seems somehow especially attractive to me.
You may also enjoy this new English band called The Moody Blues (not sure if they've crossed the Atlantic yet). Their lead guitarist and singer is named Denny Laine.
Sorry for the duplication — for some reason, my first version failed to appear even after I waited and refreshed a couple of times, so I assumed I'd hit a wrong button somewhere.
So, more "klutz" than "hero," clearly.
You're forgiven!
"Plague on Kryder II" (the table of contents says "of," by the way, which doesn't make sense) was readable, with a fairly interesting plot, but there was a lot of repetition in the narration.
"Shortstack" had its moments, but mostly of technical interest only (particularly to someone who understands the engineering more than I do.)
"Contrast" showed some imagination in the wide array of deadly critters. It's basically the author's usual "wise Earthling defeats the foolish alien" with "tourist" instead of "alien."
"Rescue Operation" was quite good. Very well-written, interesting background, solid story with an important point to make.
"The Equalizer" was an effective fable, if maybe a little too neatly contrived to make its point.
Not a bad story in the issue, and one very good one. Things may be looking up; for Analog.
Definitely a big change for the better for Analog.
I have to admit that my first reaction to the idea that the moon affects weather patterns is to roll my eyes. Having the article appear in Analog doesn't help. But the data as presented are interesting. On the other hand, let us not forget what Mark Twain (unless it was Disraeli) said about statistics.
I'm not as bothered by Leinster's "Hemingwayitis" as Gideon is, but — and I love the Med Ship stories — this series is becoming increasingly formulaic. And to combat that, the plagues are becoming increasingly unlikely and unnatural. This was a fun read, though, and better than Calhoun and Murgatroyd's last outing.
The Richmonds lost me almost immediately (not that they were in a good starting position; I wouldn't miss them in the least if they never wrote again). They clearly have never seen a desert and think they are all sand and heat. The Mojave is almost completely rocky. There are sand dunes, but not where this story is set. And deserts are cold! At night and in the winter, anyway. Questionable at best, this marvelous system probably won't work at all over half the time.
The Anvil was all right. Very smug and not his best work, by any means. I'm pretty sure sending tourists off to their deaths like that would attract a lot of attention.
Reynolds finished strong and more in form for him. It was also nice to see that Joe Mauser hadn't been corrupted by his elevation in caste. He had seemed a trifle out of character.
The Harrison was excellent. I was almost surprised to find it Analog, to be honest.
The Spinrad felt somehow familiar. Have we seen something along the same lines recently? In any case, a story to make you think.
So a good issue in an otherwise weak month. Can Campbell keep it up? Unlikely. Even less likely is that the other editors will continue to be subpar.
Campbell has , since about 1950, shown a fondness for the 'page 2' story. Leinster’s Interstellar Medical Service fits that bill. Problem solving stories set in the same 'future-history' (so to speak)…. Campbell has favored this for a long time now, and it's not just Leinster writing them. I think Gold and Galaxy blew Campbell out of the tub in the 1950s , still, I find all these domesticated space operas in ASF entertaining .